Paul Sculthorpe has slated the current St Helens playing squad, stating they are “not good enough”, after another poor performance against top four contenders Leigh Leopards.
Leigh ran out 16-4 victors at the Totally Wicked Stadium last Thursday, which ended the Saints’ five match winning run.
They beat Salford Red Devils twice, Leeds Rhinos twice and Hull FC in the streak, but Sculthorpe is not impressed with the current state of the squad.
Writing in his regular column for the St Helens Star, Sculthorpe bemoaned the players and their effort areas.
He said: “It’s clear when we play the better teams in the Betfred Super League that this current squad is not good enough.
“Beating Leigh was always going to be a tough ask, having them beaten the top two teams in the league in previous weeks and riding high on confidence sat in third.”
Do St Helens need a change in recruitment policy?
Sculthorpe played alongside current Saints coach Paul Wellens for over 200 games, including the 2001, 2004 and 2006 Challenge Cup Finals. However, the former loose forward has made his feeling very clear about his former teammates playing group.
He said: “Poor skill and poor discipline is killing them, and yet again you have to question the recruitment this season.
“If you are going to bring players over from the other side of the world, they’ve got to be significantly better than what is available in this country. Saints’ signings haven’t shown that.”
Saints currently have many key players off contract at the end of the year, including Curtis Sironen, Matt Whitley and Moses Mbye. Sculthorpe believes a new recruitment model is needed if Saints are going to be successful.
He argued: “Alongside an aging squad, the club have a major rebuild on their hands if we are to challenge for silverware anytime soon.
“There are some obvious gems who to build the side around namely Robertson, Delaney, Stephens and Dagnall, but this needs to happen now.”
Paul Wellens has a number of young talents coming through the ranks, but as with any successful team, they need experienced and proven heads to guide them as they develop into first team regulars.
One person that has been heavily linked with Saints is Josh Papali’i, who until this week looked set to be joining the club from Canberra Raiders.
Sculthorpe admitted that losing out on his signature would be a huge blow for the side.
He said: “One huge signing for the club would be that of the current Canberra and Queensland prop Josh Papali’i, however, there’s suggestions the Green Machine are set to present a one year extension to their most capped player.
“This would be a huge blow for the Saints, who desperately want the Origin winner to be their first recruit for 2026.”