Connect with us

Championship

Championship clubs outline major IMG flaws as on-field promotion deemed necessity

A number of Championship clubs have released statements following the announcement of the 2026 IMG rankings.

The gradings, which were quietly made non-compulsory for this season, ranks rugby league clubs in the Super League and second tier on five key pillars: Fandom, Finance, Stadium, Community and On-Field Performance.

Used to determine whether a club is worthy of top-flight status, this year has seen a change in criteria, and as a result it has meant that a lot of sides have seen their score decrease from 2025.

Some have said that the gradings aren’t fit for purpose, whilst others agree that the benchmarks should remain, however they should not determine promotion or relegation.

Starting with Oldham, who placed 20th out of the 26 clubs that submitted data, they have explained that one minor and meaningless detail means that they have missed out on one whole IMG point.

Director Gary Kershaw released a statement explaining why the club have received the ranking they have, and called out a major flaw in the system. Accusing some second-tier clubs of lying about their attendance figures, he said: “Whilst I have been absent from a couple of home games since taking over, I have been an ever-present at all away matches.

“On a couple of these occasions, I have been quite shocked to hear the announced attendance at these games, which, quite frankly, has been completely exaggerated.

“I can recall one game where the stated attendance was in excess of 2,000, but when I spoke to one of the opposition’s Directors, he confessed to me that it was nearer 1,300 than 2,000. When I asked why they had done this, I got a very short, succinct answer: “IMG”.”

The Roughyeds Director also went on to berate the stadium pillar of the gradings. He said: “Without being disrespectful to other clubs, I can only think of Doncaster where I would rate the facilities on a par with Boundary Park [Oldham’s home ground].

“If I drill down into the data, we have been deducted one point because the TV gantry at Boundary Park is a couple of feet shorter than it needs to be.”

Kershaw goes on to state that Oldham Athletic, the EFL club they groundshare with, have no problems using the gantry to broadcast their games live on Sky Sports.

Barrow Raiders and Widnes Vikings share IMG views after gradings revealed

Cumbrian side Barrow, who bowed out of this year’s sudden-death play-offs, finished above all other Championship sides – including London Broncos, who are heavily expected to gain promotion.

They respect why the IMG gradings are in place, but are adamant in their view that they should not decide promotion and relegation – that should be left to the clubs on-field.

As it stands, Barrow are in the best position to be promoted. However, even they have conceded that their ground, Craven Park, isn’t Super League ready.

“Unfortunately, Craven Park is not fit for Super League and there is little prospect of being able to expand and improve given its location,” the club said in their statement.

Widnes Vikings, meanwhile, have stated that they believe the gap between Super League and the Championship has been driven further apart due to the IMG criteria.

They said: “We believe that changes to the criteria used within the grading pillars have created a greater divide between the Championship and Super League. In our view, this is contrary to the original intention of IMG grading, which was to create a framework that would help clubs improve and ultimately provide a pathway towards greater competitiveness across the game.

“We remain happy to participate in IMG grading as a benchmarking tool, and we will continue to use it to identify areas where Widnes Vikings can improve.

“However, our position remains firmly that, as with any professional sporting competition, promotion and relegation must ultimately be determined by performance on the field, subject to clubs meeting appropriate minimum standards.”

Widnes certainly have a point, with the gap in points between all 14 Super League clubs sitting at 4.61, and the gap between 14th (York Knights) and 15th (Barrow) sitting at 3.39.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Must See

More in Championship